Thursday, April 26, 2012

Stigma & prejudice in mental health

Stigma is a trending topic in mental health, although not much in the media. There are several campaigns underway in Australia, mainly utilising posters plus occasional TV Specials & radio. As an individual I haven't noticed much from these campaigns- maybe a fefw Tweets, some sidebars on blogs & a little in specialist health news pages in newspapers or online.

What I HAVE noticed is a moderate amount of actual stigmatisation and prejudice towards the mentally ill, especially concerning public figures, eg. actors or politicians. I'm refusing to use the term "celebrity" any more in the hope that its use will decrease- one can only try!

My personal encounter with prejudice against the mentally ill took the form of a Twitter "conversation" with broadcaster & popular comedian and Gruen Transfer host Wil Anderson [Twitter @Wil_Anderson]. I've known him through media for many years, although I've been no particular fan or knocker- he has seemed a pleasant and positive guy. My opinion was shattered when I saw him post a very negative comment about Matthew Newton (the guy I previously wrote about in my post "...").
Here are some images of the Tweets in question:







_________________________________

Short-lived campaigns are not enough
Norman Sartorius
Nature 468, 163–165 (11 November 2010) doi:10.1038/468163a
Published online 10 November 2010
The stigma of mental illness will be reduced only if region-specific awareness initiatives become a permanent
fixture of health and social services, argues Norman Sartorius
_________________________________________

"
Anderson is well known as host of popular Australian panel show The Gruen Transfer and prior to that The Glass House, both on ABC. His radio and television career has made Anderson a highly recognised comedian in Australia, but he is foremost a standup comedy performer 
Anderson aroused controversy over some jokes he made about the late father of Australian Idol finalist Shannon Noll at the 2006 Melbourne International Comedy Festival.[1]


From 2001 to 2004 he was best known as one half of Triple J's breakfast radio team, co-presenting with Adam Spencer on the show which aired nationally across Australia. 
^ Speaker Profile of Wil Anderson at The Celebrity Speakers Bureau


Media Madness: Public Images of Mental Illness
 By Otto F. Wahl was worried when reprinting for 2nd edition that lots might have written etc but not.
David Granirer is a counsellor, stand-up comic, the author of The Happy Neurotic: How Fear and Angst can lead to Happiness and Success, and the founder of Stand Up For Mental Health.[1] David lives with his wife and two kids in Vancouver, BC.

^ video: David Granirer's Take on Stigma at http://www.youtube.com/watch?gl=CA&hl=en&v=_TUCjBWV7IA^ http://www.standupformentalhealth.com

http://www.standupformentalhealth.com/documents/Cracking-Up-Mental-Illness-and-Stand-Up-Comedy-A-Social-Representations-Approach-to-Anti-Stigma-Resistance.pdf on May 17, 2010
^ David Granirer Mental Health Consultin

Challenging the Stigma of Mental Illness

Challenging the Stigma of Mental Illness, Patrick Corrigan, David Roe and Hector Tsang,ChichesterWiley, 2011, pp. 224, ISBN 978–0–470–68360–6 (hb), £60.00
  1. Jerry Tew
+Author Affiliations
  1. Applied Social Studies, University of Birmingham
Understanding and challenging stigma are pressing issues for people with mental health difficulties and for those involved in service provision or mental health promotion. It is currently the focus of national alliances and campaigns such as ‘Time to Change’ in England, ‘See Me’ in Scotland', ‘See Change’ in Ireland and ‘Opening Minds’ in Canada. While there may be a broad consensus that the impact of social stigma may be seriously damaging to people's self-esteem and impair their chances of recovery, there is still a relatively weak evidence base as to what may be effective in tackling stigma (Yanos et al., 2008;Tew et al., 2011).
In Challenging the Stigma of Mental Illness, Patrick Corrigan and colleagues seek to provide a practically focused text that is grounded in the experience and narratives of …

Sunday, April 8, 2012

Portrayal of mental illness on social media

Some public figures have been using Twitter & other social media to air their own prejudices about mental illness. They particularly concentrate on any OTHER public figures who appear to be having a miserable time, eg. Matthew Newton [sometime actor & presenter].

I was particularly incensed to see a local comedian and radio personality post the following about Matt Newton this morning:




If you look at Wil's statements, you'll see that he doesn't really know what mental illness is and he doesn't know what behaviours may be produced during episodes of mental illness that the "owner" might find difficult to control (or impossible if they haven't LEARNT how to control them).
You can also see that Wil wasn't monitoring the content of his own Tweets as he claims I am outrageous because I made a comment about mental illness (which was the topic I was embracing anyway) and he didn't! If I was a wellknown performer dependent on a positive reputation for income I might have been more careful. However, Wil may be relying on many of his fans having warped ideas about mental illness such that they find it amusing to hit people when they are down. I don't know how he is running his career, so I don't know if his current fans have any particular leanings- but I know when I USED TO BE a fan of his on TripleJ that I admired his ability to make clever humour out of most topics. Lucky the topic of mental illness didn't come up when I was listening to his shows, eh?!